Nau mai, haere mai, welcome to EyeContact. You are invited to respond to reviews and contribute to discussion by registering to participate.



View Discussion
Hannah Kidd, Rex (detail), steel rod, corrugated iron Hannah Kidd, Mack, steel rod, corrugated iron Hannah Kidd, Mack (detail), steel rod, corrugated iron Hannah Kidd,Tess, steel rod, corrugated iron, paint. Hannah Kidd, Tess (detail), steel rod, corrugated iron, paint. Hannah Kidd, Rex, steel rod, corrugated iron Hannah Kidd, Jock (detail), steel rod, corrugated iron Hannah Kidd, Buckley, steel rod, corrugated iron

It's the relationship between the sculptures that defines them as such, it being just as important as the forms themselves, for it is fraught with tension. The dogs are so carefully positioned we can imagine that space narrowing and trapping us in the middle. They are so life-like and the gallery space at times so quiet, that the anticipation of any bark or whistle adds to that suspenseful dynamic.



Hannah Kidd
Working Dogs


3 March - 28 March, 2012


Mack sits with his tongue out, ears flopped back and eyes shut, begging for a pat on the head. Tess rests rigidly, watching the door. Beyond these two are three others watching each other from across the room. Rex seems aggressive, staring at Buckley who stares back. Jock’s ears are pointed towards the ground as he observes Rex and Buckley from his corner. Hannah Kidd’s Working Dogs do not work. They don’t move; they don’t have eyes. Yet the feeling that they are about to run or bark is palpable. Against the backdrop of Michael Hight’s new landscapes, Kidd’s steel rod and corrugated iron creations seem very real.

Upon entering the gallery, the viewer finds themselves immediately between the three dogs who are looking at each other. I found this quite unnerving, and quickly moved over to Rex on the right so as to not get caught in a confrontation. Looking back at him from across the room, Rex’s stance is aggressive and his eyes (or lack thereof) stare intensely. The welding spots on the dogs’ coats give them a look of alarming unfamiliarity. Maybe it’s me - I’m not exactly what you would call ‘a dog person’ - but imagining being between three dogs like that left me on edge.

It’s the placement of each piece and the way they relate to each other that really make these sculptures succeed, especially the three just described. By themselves, they are pretty cool - the material is tough yet the forms are lifelike, the colouring (graying around the mouth, brown patches, white socks) is near perfect, and all are extremely well-executed. Some of Kidd’s previous animals though, like those in the Antarctic exhibition, have held their own better in a gallery space, relying on the setting up of an installed environment - a setting which becomes a necessity. One dog staring at the wall would have zero impact beyond aesthetic.

Hight’s landscapes should not be counted as part of Kidd’s environment though, as it’s the relationship between the sculptures that defines them as such, that space between being just as important as the forms themselves, for as described above, it is fraught with tension. The dogs are so carefully positioned we can imagine that space narrowing and trapping us in the middle. They are so life-like and the gallery space at times so quiet, that the anticipation of any bark or whistle adds to that suspenseful dynamic.

There were a few other visitors to the gallery during my visit, and each time the door opened, the penny dropped and the tense atmosphere was broken. Art consultant Lisa Wilkie was greeting visitors and patting the dogs, letting everyone know they were free to touch. The presence of several people in the gallery brought out the friendly side of these sculptures, that social dynamic being more interesting than the fact that the steel dogs were touchable.

The paradoxical play between rural and urban was also intriguing: farm dogs being made from steel and iron, classic industrial materials. Kidd has created all sorts of animals (and humans) from these materials, and she has said that rural life inspires her work. With the busy street outside the gallery, and the life-size dogs and New Zealand landscapes inside, I began to wonder if Hight’s work was the best backdrop for Kidd’s dogs. There was something not exactly kitsch about it, but maybe over-the-top; a dichotomy with an obviousness that stole something away from the sculptures. Had they been placed in a gallery with blank walls, the tension may have been more eloquent - the animals would have seemed out of place and yet obviously also contemporary artworks. Here, they work with the paintings, but the viewer can always place them comfortably in Kingston or Mount Pisa, where they assume they belong.

Erin Driessen

Print | Facebook | Twitter | Email


This Discussion has 5 comments.


Andrew Paul Wood, 9:26 p.m. 19 March, 2012

I like that the rivets and metal patchwork are so obvious

Reply to this thread

John Hurrell, 8:36 a.m. 20 March, 2012

Is this work just a mutty version of Jeff Thomson? Apart from craft, is there perhaps a semiotic layer, some aspect of the materials or treatment that tell us about dogs and their place in our world? Are they not too obvious?

Reply to this thread

Erin Driessen, 11:42 a.m. 20 March, 2012

Andrew, I like it too; if they were more polished they would just be props.

See what you did there, John. By themselves, even though they are technically brilliant, I find them entirely uninteresting. But in that space, positioned as they are, they go beyond anything simply semiotic and actually create quite a powerful phenomenological experience. The photos here don't evoke that, unfortunately.

Reply to this thread

Clare Logan, 9:38 a.m. 15 May, 2012

Perhaps rather than providing viewers with a comfortable point of reference to where the dogs "belong", the landscape paintings reinforce the fact that the sculptures are not, in fact, in a rural environment, instead displaced into an urban setting, emphasizing the urban/rural tension of their placement in an indoor, walled space.

 In reply

Andrew Paul Wood, 12:16 p.m. 15 May, 2012

Might be over-thinking it slightly - lots of people in urban setting own working breeds as pets. I'm not discounting it, but I don't think it's conscious.

Reply to this thread

Recent Posts by Erin Driessen

Installation view of John Panting: Spatial Constructions at the Adam Art Gallery, showing 6.08 (Untitled VIII, 1973–74, steel, 244 x 366 x 244cm. Collection of Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa, 1977-0006-1. Photo: Shaun Waugh.

Panting and Robinson Correspondence



John Panting
Spatial Constructions

Peter Robinson

Cuts and Junctures

12 October - 20 December, 2013

Installation of Emma Chalmers' Around the Block on Tenterhooks on the first floor of the University of Otago Library. Photo by Kate van der Drift

Priests and Protests

Art on Campus



Emma Chalmers
Around the Block on Tenterhooks


October - November, 2012

Installation of Carlos Wedde and Hayden Prujean's Deep Sea Dis-comedusae (2012) at Blue Oyster

Descartian Vortices and the Eternal Cycle




James R. Ford
Snake Pis
Hayden Prujean and Carlos Wedde
Deep Sea Dis-comedusae

29 August - 29 September, 2012

Neil Emmerson's inhabit me (like a memory) at Dunedin School of Art Gallery. This installation comprises a total of 20 units with the possibility of various modes of assembly. Mixed media on paper.

The Frame and the Flesh




Neil Emmerson
inhabit me (like a memory)


30 July - 17 August, 2012